Roofing Questions Homeowners Ask Around Colorado Springs
How much does a new roof cost?
Nobody can tell you what's the average roof cost for your house without measuring it. Size, steepness, material and access all move the price, and so do local rules:
- In Colorado Springs, a new roof, or a repair over 25% of the roof, has to be a Class A covering (the top fire rating), with no solid wood.
- In Cripple Creek's historic district, outside changes need city approval, called a Certificate of Appropriateness, before work starts.
For a real number, see roof replacement or send a request, and a roofer who works in the area will call you back.
How much does a roof repair cost?
A small fix, like resealing a vent boot (the rubber collar around a pipe) or replacing a few torn shingles, costs far less than patching a large section. In the Pikes Peak Regional Building Department's area, roof work over 100 square feet needs a permit, whether a contractor or you do it. Hail often bruises shingles across a whole slope, turning a patch into a bigger job, and FEMA rates El Paso County's hail risk as Relatively High. See roof repair.
Why do roofing quotes differ so much, and what changes the price?
Quotes that sit far apart usually price different work. Compare them line by line:
- Tear-off, meaning removal of the old roof. In the Pikes Peak region, new asphalt shingles go on only after every existing layer is stripped.
- Ice barrier, a sticky waterproof sheet laid along the eaves (the low edges of the roof). Teller County runs it from the lowest edge until it sits at least 72 inches past the outside wall.
- Older houses. The metro has 49972 homes built from 1970 to 1979, and handling old paint or roofing that may hold asbestos takes extra care.
Will the final bill match the estimate?
It should come close if the paperwork is clear. Colorado makes the roofer put the deal on paper, with both your signature and theirs, before any work starts. Surprises usually come from what stays hidden until the old roof is off, so ask the contract to show:
- a set price per sheet of rotten decking (the plywood under the shingles)
- separate lines for tear-off, underlayment (the sheet under the shingles), flashing (the metal that seals chimneys and walls) and cleanup
- that changes get agreed in writing before they are made
- whether the permit is included, since jobs larger than 100 square feet need a permit
Are estimates and roof inspections free?
That depends on the company, so ask when you book. Some charge for a detailed written report with photos. After big storms, like the August 6, 2018 hail that hit southern Colorado Springs with stones 3 to 4 inches across, door-to-door offers pile up. Let people look if you like, but sign nothing on the doorstep.
Can I pay over time, and do I have to put money down first?
That depends on the roofer; some work with lenders and some take payment in stages. Get loan terms in writing. A deposit for materials is common, and every Colorado roofing contract has to give you seventy-two hours after signing to back out with a full refund of the deposit. Hold the final payment until you have looked over the finished job.
At least 85% of what the Strengthen Colorado Homes program collects has to go to homeowner grants, paid for by a yearly fee on home insurers of 0.5% of premiums starting in 2027. The grants are meant for FORTIFIED roof upgrades, FORTIFIED being a standard for storm-resistant roofs, and the program is still listed as coming soon.
Will my homeowners insurance pay for a new roof?
It may, if a storm did the damage. Most policies cover sudden harm from hail or wind, not wear. Whether you get a new roof or a repair depends on what the adjuster (the insurer's inspector) finds and on your policy. Storm damage is common here: FEMA rates El Paso County's risk from tornadoes and from strong wind as Relatively High. Look up your deductible, the share you pay yourself.
How does a roof insurance claim work, will the roofer meet my adjuster, and what do I do when the insurance check comes?
- Photograph the damage from the ground, plus any stains inside.
- Call your insurer to open a claim, and note the claim number.
- Have a roofer inspect, so you know the damage before the adjuster comes.
- Ask the roofer to be there for the adjuster's visit; many will, and it helps nothing get missed.
- The check may name you and your mortgage lender, and insurers often hold back part until the work is done.
- Don't sign the check over before the work is finished.
If the insurer denies all or part of the claim, Colorado lets you cancel a roofing contract you signed within seventy-two hours after that denial.
If insurance pays, do I still owe my deductible? Can a roofer cover it for me?
Yes, you owe it. Colorado law bars a roofer on an insurance-paid job from advertising or offering to cover, skip or hand back any piece of your deductible. Contractors paid through a Strengthen Colorado Homes grant can't waive it either. Walk away if you hear:
- "We'll take care of your deductible."
- "This roof won't cost you anything."
- a "discount" that happens to match your deductible
What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value for my roof?
Replacement cost pays what a comparable new roof costs today, less your deductible. Actual cash value pays only what the old roof was worth after wear, which can be far less. Many replacement cost policies pay the actual cash value up front and release the rest, called recoverable depreciation, after the work is done. With hail risk rated Relatively High in El Paso County and Relatively Moderate in Teller County, check which kind you have before the next storm.
How long do I have to file a roof claim, and will a claim raise my premium?
Your policy sets the deadline, so read the section on reporting a loss or ask your agent. Report damage soon after a storm, while it is easy to tie to a date. Storms are no rarity here: FEMA counts 71 tornado events in El Paso County. Whether a claim raises your premium depends on your insurer and your history, so ask how weather claims are treated. Skipping a real claim can leave you paying for damage that spreads.
Can a stronger roof (impact-resistant shingles or a FORTIFIED roof) lower my insurance bill?
Often, but each insurer decides how much:
- If hail has ruined your roof and it has to be replaced, Colorado's Insurance Division says to find out from your insurer whether a hail-resistant roof earns a premium discount or trims future deductibles.
- Insurers report yearly the discount they give for a resilient roof, though the law sets no amount.
- In state law, a resilient roof means a roof certified as FORTIFIED for wind and hail, or by a similar program.
- The state's summary form for home policies lists the kind of roof among the things that may raise or cut your premium.
Ask your insurer what proof it wants before you buy.
Are impact-resistant or architectural shingles worth the extra cost?
Architectural shingles are thicker and layered, and usually handle wind better than flat, basic shingles. Impact-resistant shingles are built and tested to take hard hits. Here the case is strong: on August 6, 2018, a storm out of Teller County struck the Cheyenne Mountain Zoo and the south side of the city with hail measuring 3 to 4 inches across, and the damage was put at $173 million. Weigh the extra cost against any premium break, and watch for state grants toward upgrades that earn FORTIFIED or similar certification.
How fast can someone come after a storm, and can they tarp my roof until it is fixed?
That depends on how many homes were hit and on the weather. After a big wind event like December 15, 2021, when gusts reached 101 mph near Manitou Springs, roofers across the region are booked, and nobody can honestly promise an arrival time. A tarp, heavy plastic fastened over the damage, keeps water out until the repair, so ask for it as a separately priced job. Before any roofing work, Colorado calls for a contract in writing that you and the roofer sign. See emergency roof repair.
What are the signs of roof or hail damage, and can I see them from the ground?
Many show from the yard:
- dents in gutters, downspouts and vent caps
- granules, the sandy shingle coating, piled at downspouts
- missing, lifted or creased shingles after wind
- a roof line that dips after heavy snow
- thick ice along the edge, a sign of ice dams (ice ridges that trap meltwater)
- stains on ceilings or in the attic
Bruised shingles and broken seals need someone on the roof to spot them. FEMA's records put the yearly average for El Paso County at between six and seven hail events, so look after every big storm. See storm damage repair.
Why does my roof leak, how do I find where it is coming from, and does a leak mean I need a new roof?
Most leaks start at weak points:
- flashing around chimneys, skylights and walls
- rubber boots around plumbing vents, which crack in the sun
- ice dams pushing meltwater under shingles
- hail or wind damage, or nails that have worked loose
Take a flashlight into the attic during or soon after rain and look for wet wood. Water runs along the rafters, the sloped framing boards, so the drip is often lower than the hole. A leak rarely means a new roof; most are fixed with a repair. See roof leak repair.
What are ice dams, and how do I stop them?
Ice dams are thick bands of ice that build up along the eaves. Heat from the house melts snow higher up, the water freezes at the cold edge, and later melt backs up under the shingles. To prevent them, seal air leaks into the attic, add insulation, keep attic vents clear, and pull snow off the lower edge with a roof rake from the ground.
The ice barrier under the shingles is the backup. Teller County calls for it on heated buildings, Woodland Park's rules want it from the lowest edges to a spot 72 inches or more inside the house's outer wall, and El Paso County homes above 7,000 feet need it to reach at least 24 inches inside the wall.
Do I need a repair or a whole new roof?
A repair usually fits when the damage is in a small area and the rest of the roof lies flat with its granules intact. A new roof makes more sense when:
- hail has bruised shingles across whole slopes
- shingles curl, crack or show bare spots in many places
- the same leaks keep coming back
- the deck feels soft underfoot
A patch covering over 100 square feet needs a permit in the Pikes Peak region, just like a new roof.
What happens if the wood under my shingles is rotten?
It gets cut out and replaced before anything new goes on. The deck only shows its condition when the old roofing comes off, and in the Pikes Peak region a new asphalt roof can't go over old layers anyway. Ask for a price per sheet in the contract and photos of the bad wood, and ask the roofer to find what caused the rot.
How do I pick a good roofing company I can trust to be around after the job?
Look for:
- a local address and an office phone, not just a cell number on a flyer
- references from jobs done a while ago
- a workmanship warranty in writing
- no offer to handle your deductible, which Colorado bars roofers on insurance jobs from making
Be wary of storm chasers, crews who follow big hail storms from town to town and leave when the claims dry up.
Is the roofer licensed and insured, and do they use their own workers or subcontractors?
Get a certificate of insurance for liability and workers' compensation sent straight from their agent. Ask who will do the work, who supervises on site and who you call if something goes wrong. Subcontractors can do fine work, but the company that signs your contract should stand behind it.
What warranties come with a roof, and how is a maker's warranty different from a workmanship warranty?
- Maker's warranty. The shingle or metal maker covers defects in the product, often not installation mistakes, and coverage may depend on registering the roof.
- Workmanship warranty. The installer covers their own work, such as leaks from bad flashing or nailing, and it is only as good as the installer's staying power.
Get each in writing, note what voids it, and ask whether it passes to a buyer if you sell.
Can I cancel a roofing contract after I sign it?
Yes, within set windows:
- After signing. The contract has to include a clause letting you back out within seventy-two hours of signing, with your deposit returned in full.
- After a claim denial. When insurance is meant to pay and the insurer turns down any part of the claim, you get seventy-two hours from the denial to cancel.
Cancel in writing and keep proof of when you sent it.
Do I need a permit for a new roof, and who gets it?
Almost always. Building permits in Colorado Springs come from the Pikes Peak Regional Building Department, which requires a permit for roof repair or replacement above 100 square feet, even when the owner does the work. Have your roofer pull the permit in the company's name, so the company answers for the work. Where to ask:
- Pikes Peak Regional Building Department: 2880 International Circle, Colorado Springs, CO 80910; permit desk 719-327-2883, open 7:30am to 4:15pm; www.pprbd.org.
- Teller County Building Division: 800 Research Drive, Suite 100-B, Woodland Park, CO 80863; 719-687-3048; www.tellercounty.gov/Building-Division.
- Cripple Creek Building Department: (719) 689-3588 x1; www.cityofcripplecreek.com/building-department.
Does my HOA, city or state limit what roof material or color I can use?
Yes:
- Colorado Springs has required Class A roof coverings on homes since an ordinance of January 1, 2003, ruling out solid wood roofing.
- In Cripple Creek's Wildfire Protection Overlay, replace or repair at least 25% of the roof covering and the entire roof has to meet the wildfire code.
- In Cripple Creek's historic district, guidelines for historic homes lean toward quiet tones like grey, dark brown, dark green or dark red, and mixed-color (variegated) shingles don't fit.
- Your HOA can review looks, but Colorado law does not let it demand cedar shakes or any roofing that burns easily, and an HOA rule banning fire-hardened materials is void.
Can I fix my roof myself?
Small jobs from a ladder are fine; on the roof, falls are the main danger and mistakes show up later as leaks. Homeowners in the regional building department's area still need a permit to repair or replace more than 100 square feet of roof. That area builds to the 2021 International Residential Code with regional changes, and Teller County uses the 2021 code with its own amendments. The metro also has 25080 homes built from 1960 to 1969 and 14611 built in 1939 or earlier, so test old paint for lead and old roofing for asbestos before you scrape or tear.
Which roofing material is best for my home and my weather, and is metal a good choice?
- Asphalt shingles are the most common and cost least up front; impact-resistant versions take hail better. See asphalt shingle roofing.
- Metal handles wind and fire well and sheds snow, but it can dent in hail, and sliding snow may call for snow guards (brackets that hold snow in place) over doors. See metal roofing.
- Concrete or clay tile is heavy, and Teller County sets the snow weight buildings are designed for at 57 pounds per square foot on the ground, so have the framing checked before adding tile. See tile roofing.
Hail matters more in El Paso County, rated Relatively High by FEMA, than in Teller County, rated Relatively Moderate.
Can new shingles go over my old roof, or does the old roof have to come off?
In the Pikes Peak region, it comes off: local reroof guidelines don't allow new asphalt shingles until every existing layer is gone. Elsewhere, a roof-over (new shingles laid on old) hides rotten decking, adds weight and leaves no bare deck at the eaves for an ice barrier. A tear-off lets the roofer see the deck, fix it and seal it properly.
What kind of roof and attic vents does my home need?
Most homes need air coming in low and going out high. Intake vents in the soffits, the undersides of the eaves, let outside air in; exhaust vents near the ridge, the roof's peak, let warm, damp air out. That keeps the attic cold in winter, which helps prevent ice dams, and cooler in summer. El Paso County's wildfire rules reach unincorporated wildland-urban interface beyond any fire district; there, ask about vents with fine mesh that keeps embers out.
Should I replace my gutters or add gutter guards when I get a new roof?
Often, yes. The drip edge, the metal strip along the roof edge, should tuck neatly into the gutters, and a new roof is the easy time to line them up. Replace gutters that sag, leak at the seams or pull away from the house. Guards keep pine needles and leaves out, which matters in wildfire country, where dry debris can catch embers; pick a type that lets snow slide off. See gutter installation.
How long does it take to replace a roof?
The roof work usually takes a few days on a typical house, longer for steep or complicated roofs, extra layers, rotten decking or bad weather. Allow time before that too: in Colorado Springs, the roofer gets the permit through the Pikes Peak Regional Building Department, and materials have to arrive. In Cripple Creek's historic district, the city's roofing review can take up to ten business days from a complete application. Lead-safe work on older painted trim adds time as well.
What time of year is best to put on a new roof?
Late spring through early fall is easiest, because shingles seal down best in warm sun. Winter work is possible on mild, dry days, though shingles may need hand-sealing and snow can stall the job. Try to finish before winter: El Paso County homes at or above 7,000 feet are designed for 57 pounds per square foot of snow on the ground, and a damaged roof is a poor thing to carry into that season. Summer storms fill roofers' calendars, so book in spring if you can.
Do I need to be home, how do I get ready, and how will my yard and house be protected?
You don't need to be home all day, but stay reachable. To get ready:
- move cars away from the house
- take pictures and mirrors off the walls, since hammering shakes them
- cover things stored in the attic
- keep pets and children away from the work
Ask how the yard will be protected: tarps over plants, boards against walls and a magnet sweep for nails. In older homes, ask about painted trim and fascia, the board along the roof edge. Colorado's lead safety pamphlet rule covers renovations disturbing at least 2 square feet of paint in homes built before 1978, and EPA runs that program here.
How long will my roof last?
It depends on the material, the quality of the install, attic venting and the weather it faces. Hail is a major threat here, with El Paso County's hail risk in FEMA's Relatively High band, and a severe storm can end any roof's life early. Ask what to expect from the material you pick, keep the warranty papers, and have the roof checked after big storms.
How often should my roof be checked, and what upkeep does it need?
Have it looked at each spring and fall and after any big hail or wind storm. Wind here can be extreme: on December 15, 2021, gusts hit 100 mph at the US Air Force Academy. Simple upkeep:
- clean gutters and downspouts each fall
- trim branches away from the roof
- check sealant around vents, chimneys and skylights
- rake heavy snow off the lower edge from the ground
- call for a check if the roof sags or doors stick after heavy snow
To arrange a roof inspection, send a request.